How Toronto craft beers get on LCBO shelves
An edited version of this post originally appeared on blogTO on March 6, 2012.
While Toronto beer fans should be excited that we’ll now have a chance to take home a little more local variety from the city’s burgeoning craft beer scene, the accomplishment is all the more admirable when one has a little knowledge of just how daunting the LCBO’s process can be.
The first thing a brewer needs to do if he or she is interested in selling his or her product at the LCBO is apply to the LCBO’s Trading Partner Access Request system (TPAR). Once your TPAR request is granted, you’ll have access to various LCBO web-based systems, including the New Item Submission System (NISS). Once a brewer has access to NISS…
OK, you know what? I haven’t even got to the official application part yet and the acronym count is already at three. Let me break it down for you: the process is about as tedious and process-driven as one might expect from the provincial government. Essentially, getting approval from the LCBO comprises six complicated steps, each of which can take a month or more.
First a brewer needs to submit to a product evaluation which includes, among other things, taste testings.
Then the approval process begins and the LCBO submits the product for chemical analysis and reviews the brewer’s marketing plan as well as his or her packaging and art.
At this point the LCBO may offer a preliminary decision to purchase, which can include a commitment letter outlining further stipulations the brewer needs to meet before they get the OK.
If these stipulations are met, the LCBO will issue a purchase order, which might further include terms and conditions. Depending on where the product is being imported from, this part might take up to 16 weeks.
Once the products are shipped, they sit in a warehouse while a second lab test is conducted, a final price is determined, and stores with suitable demographics are identified to start with an introductory offer.
It’s enough to make you need a drink, really.
Despite all this, Brock Shepherd, owner of the Kensington Brewing Company, isn’t discouraged. “My experience has been really positive,” he says, “albeit daunting.”
On meeting the requirements, Shepherd notes, “You need to navigate their system and learn their way. The beer and cider administrator Gisele [Renaud] has been amazingly helpful. They are very supportive of Ontario craft beer, so that helps a lot.”
On top of starting Double Trouble with his longtime friend Nathan Dunsmoor, Claude Lefebvre is also the head of North American Craft, essentially a marketing agency that focuses on the needs of small craft brewers. Along with helping often new-to-marketing craft brewers with sales plans, North American Craft acts as the the agent of record for these brewers at the LCBO, so Lefebvre has some experience with the “jumping through hoops” that is required.
“You do have to go through a process, and it’s a timely one, but it makes a lot of sense,” he says. It’s also not always as cut-and-dried as the outline I’ve provided. Sometimes any number of these steps can take a lot longer than expected; however, ultimately, it’s worth the effort. Lefebvre notes that a large percentage of craft beer sales comes from the retail market and that’s where he and Dunsmoor plan to focus their efforts for the time being. He notes that this provides them an opportunity to can focus on making and marketing their beer, then essentially “hand over the distribution to the experts, the LCBO.”
Shepherd is likewise supportive of the process and notes that it could be worse. “I look at it this way, we could be like the U.S. with a wide open system, but then you have to deal with distributors, each individual store, etc. — more middle men. People may complain about the LCBO, but we’ve got it pretty good.”
Augusta Ale, the first of Shepherd’s beers in what is planned as a series of micro-brews from Kensington, seems poised to do well with the take-home market. It’s got just enough flavour to please fans of more complex beers without scaring off people who are intimidated by hops (i.e. that guy that keeps commenting on every thing I write about craft beer). It’s a clean, crisp, American-style pale ale with some malt and caramel flavour and should be a welcome addition to a beer enthusiast’s shopping list during the approaching patio season (What? I’m an optimist. It’s almost Spring isn’t it?)
Hops and Robbers, on the other hand, is a fairly complex golden IPA that brings a bit more bite to the table owing to the brewery’s dry hopping with cascade hops. Not only are they made by small, local companies with a passion for beer, they’re also both brewed under the experienced and watchful eye of brewmaster Paul Dickey at Black Oak’s facilities.
Dickey has been brewing beer since 1986 and is currently a Grand Master Level One Judge with the Beer Judge Certification Program. He has brewed beer at Denison’s Brewing Company, Pepperwood Bistro and Brewery in Burlington, and was the head brewer at the Black Oak Brewing Company in Oakville until he began his own venture, Cheshire Valley Brewing Company. Among others, Paul is responsible for the creation of the Black Oak Saison and Nutcracker, and Mill Street’s Coffee Porter.
If none of that makes any sense to you, I’ll summarize: This dude knows his beer.
And soon you’ll be able to take home some of that beer. Shepherd estimates Augusta Ale will finally be available in stores in a few months and the guys from Double Trouble are optimistic that Hops and Robbers will be in the LCBO by May 2-4 weekend.
With a little patience, these local options should keep coming.